Rohit Bhagnani, Chief Product Officer at MagicBricks, shares profound insights from his early sales career at Dabur. He reveals how understanding local context, human psychology, and partner incentives—even when they defy official policies—is crucial for driving long-term sales success and avoiding market share erosion.
You can't abuse your dominant relationship in a business in a sales engagement because then the other guy will find a way work around.
In his initial sales role, Rohit Bhagnani was assigned to the politically charged Northeast of India. His regional manager quickly advised him to shed his formal corporate attire—shirt, tie, and polished shoes—in favor of blue jeans, a simple t-shirt, and rubber chappals. This unconventional directive was crucial for his success.
By blending in with the local shopkeepers and their humble environments, Rohit was able to dismantle artificial barriers of formality. This adaptation allowed him to connect authentically, building trust and rapport far more effectively than any formal posturing could have achieved.
During his time at Dabur, Rohit encountered a distributor in Delhi who purchased a popular product for ₹970 but consistently sold it to retailers for ₹950—seemingly at a loss. Intrigued, Rohit investigated and uncovered the distributor's ingenious methods for maintaining profitability.
The distributor strategically cross-sold high-margin, slower-moving products like Dabur sharbat alongside the popular item. Additionally, he collected and sold the empty cardboard cases, generating a consistent ₹30 per case. This demonstrated that official pricing often doesn't tell the full story of a partner's true economic incentives.
In the Northeast, Dabur's distributors faced inefficient supply chains, forcing them to hold 3-4 months of inventory. To offset their increased carrying costs and capital lockup, these distributors sold products at ₹1050, exceeding the official ₹1000 price point. This "optimization" by the distributors had a detrimental effect on Dabur.
While Dabur held a dominant position, failing to address the distributors' operational realities led to higher retail prices. In categories where retailers had alternative brands, this price disparity caused Dabur to lose market share. The lesson was clear: exercising dominance without empathy for partners' profitability can erode long-term market presence.
The Delhi Dabur distributor, despite the seemingly low margins on individual products, achieved remarkable profitability due to his astute management of working capital. He benefited from a 70-day credit period from Dabur, allowing him to receive products without immediate payment.
Simultaneously, he collected immediate cash payments from retailers. This created a powerful negative working capital cycle, meaning he operated with minimal personal capital investment. This cash flow optimization allowed him to maximize his return on investment, proving that real returns often stem from efficient capital management rather than just nominal product margins.
Formal attire can inadvertently create a barrier between a salesperson and customers, especially in informal or humble settings. By adapting one's appearance to mirror the local environment, as Rohit did in the Northeast, salespeople can foster genuine connection and build trust more effectively, making the customer feel understood and respected.
As seen with the Dabur distributor in Delhi, who sold below cost but made profit from cross-selling and selling packaging, or the Northeast distributors who raised prices due to inventory costs, partners will always find ways to ensure their business thrives. Companies must look beyond official policies to understand these underlying profit drivers to effectively manage partnerships.
Dabur's strong market position initially allowed it to impose long inventory cycles on distributors. However, this eventually led to distributors increasing retail prices, causing customers to switch to competitors in competitive categories. This demonstrates that short-term enforcement without considering partner incentives can lead to long-term market share erosion for the dominant company.
"What are the typical operating costs for a business like yours in this specific locality, beyond just product purchase?"
Purpose: Uncover hidden financial pressures & local context."How do your customers prefer to pay, and what are your typical credit cycles with them?"
Purpose: Understand working capital dynamics."Are there any unofficial revenue streams or cost-saving tactics unique to your business or region that help you maintain profitability?"
Purpose: Identify hidden profit levers & unofficial optimizations."What are the biggest challenges you face with inventory management and supply chain reliability in this market?"
Purpose: Gauge impact of company policies on partner operations."Beyond the product itself, what truly drives customer loyalty and repeat business in your specific segment?"
Purpose: Understand local customer psychology & value drivers."If our product margins were tighter, what alternative strategies would you consider to ensure your overall business remains profitable?"
Purpose: Proactively identify potential workarounds and competitive risks.Go beyond official reports. Observe, listen, and immerse yourself in your customers' environment. Understanding their unspoken needs, local culture, and operational quirks is more valuable than any corporate sales manual.
Your partners will always optimize for their own survival and profit. Instead of fighting it, design your pricing, credit, and product mix to naturally align with their profit levers, even the unconventional ones, to secure long-term loyalty and market penetration.
A universal brand message might miss the mark. Learn how local economic realities, cultural norms, and distribution channels impact product perception and sales. Adapt your messaging to resonate with the specific context of each market segment.
Your ability to adapt, observe, and build rapport in diverse, real-world scenarios will be your greatest asset. Seek out experiences that challenge your assumptions and force you to understand human behavior and local dynamics beyond theory.
Each side will optimize.
Join thousands of Indian professionals learning from industry experts.
Explore All Courses →