Rana, founder and CEO of Darkspot Needs, reveals a critical mistake entrepreneurs make when building online-first consumer brands. He argues that the inherent characteristics of a product and its category, especially pricing and margins, are paramount for online success, often overriding passion or market familiarity. Businesses must select products with sufficient profitability to cover the unique costs of e-commerce, or risk failure.
One of the biggest problems I see is that the category or product chosen is not something which will fly online.
Before committing to an online-first brand, entrepreneurs must rigorously assess if their chosen product category is inherently suitable for e-commerce. Factors such as pricing, physical weight, and volume significantly impact the overall profitability within an online sales model.
Rana highlights common over-the-counter (OTC) pain relief products, like a hypothetical "Volani" spray, which might retail for 100-200 rupees. The low retail price, coupled with high logistics fees and platform commissions, makes online sales for such items highly unprofitable. This is especially true if the brand lacks a massive offline presence to absorb these costs as marketing.
For online-first brands, product selection must be driven by the imperative to secure sufficient margins. These margins must comfortably cover all variable costs associated with e-commerce, including logistics, warehousing, platform commissions, marketing, and potential returns, extending far beyond just the cost of goods sold.
Consider a product priced at 100-200 rupees; Rana explains that logistics alone can consume 50-60 rupees. This leaves an inadequate margin to cover other operational and marketing expenses. He proposes an ideal product pricing of around 1500 rupees as a "risk-mitigated option" to ensure a healthy buffer for all e-commerce related costs.
It's crucial to distinguish the primary purpose of an online channel. While 'online first' brands aim for direct sales profitability, established brands with vast offline distribution often use online platforms primarily for marketing and brand visibility, rather than as a significant direct sales contributor.
Large corporations with extensive offline networks might list low-margin products online and invest heavily in digital marketing. Their online sales, often contributing only 1-5% of total revenue, are not profit-driven but serve as a critical marketing medium to capture consumer attention and maintain brand presence.
The physical characteristics of a product, particularly its weight and volume, are pivotal in determining logistics costs. For online sales, these costs can rapidly erode margins, especially for lower-priced items, rendering certain products unviable for an e-commerce model.
A 1kg bottle of dog shampoo, for example, priced at 200-300 rupees, often becomes unprofitable once the significant logistics costs for its weight are factored in. In contrast, high-value, small, and light items like mobile accessories, or premium dog food (which is bulky but commands a high price and good margin), tend to perform much better. Rana recalls the failure of early e-commerce ventures like pets.com due to the insurmountable logistics costs relative to product margins.
Identifying an optimal price range for your product is essential to ensure comfortable profitability online. Prices that are too low will be quickly consumed by fixed logistics and platform fees, while prices that are excessively high might face strong market resistance and deter potential customers.
Rana suggests a price point of approximately 1500 rupees as a "fair risk-mitigated option" for products sold online. While some products around 500 rupees can succeed, this is typically only if they are exceptionally small and light, thereby keeping logistics costs to an absolute minimum and preserving margins.
Beyond your specific product, evaluate the inherent profitability of the entire product category within the online ecosystem. A thorough analysis of existing market pricing and the competitive landscape is crucial to determine if a category can actually support the necessary margins for an online-first business.
In the OTC pain relief spray category, where products typically retail for 100-200 rupees, new online-first brands face significant challenges. Established players often use online channels more for marketing than direct profit, leveraging their offline scale to absorb losses. This makes it incredibly difficult for new entrants to compete profitably online.
Any product can be sold successfully online if marketed effectively.
Products must possess appropriate pricing, weight, and inherent margins to absorb the substantial costs of logistics, warehousing, and platform fees. Attempting to sell low-value, high-volume items online without a massive offline brand presence for marketing will often lead to unprofitability and business failure, no matter how clever the marketing.
A low cost of goods directly translates to higher profit potential for online products.
Even if a product costs only 50 rupees to produce, if the market only supports a 150-200 rupee selling price, and logistics/platform fees consume 50-60 rupees, the remaining margin for marketing and profit is too thin. The market price must be high enough to comfortably cover all variable costs associated with online distribution, not just the manufacturing cost.
Online sales platforms are primarily a direct sales channel for all businesses.
These companies list products online and invest in marketing, even if online sales contribute only 1-5% of their total revenue. They view these platforms as a means to capture eyeballs and maintain brand presence, not necessarily for direct online profit generation. New online-first brands, however, cannot afford this marketing-first, profit-later strategy and must prioritize direct sales profitability.
Before any significant investment, rigorously assess your product category's inherent suitability for online sales. Consider factors like average selling price, physical weight, and volume to understand potential logistics and platform costs.
Design your product and pricing strategy to ensure sufficient margins. These margins must comfortably cover not just the cost of goods, but also logistics, warehousing, platform commissions, marketing, and returns, aiming for a price point that offers a healthy buffer.
Thoroughly calculate how product weight and volume will affect shipping costs. Avoid low-value, heavy, or bulky items that will quickly become unprofitable due to high last-mile delivery expenses.
Clearly determine whether your online presence is primarily for direct sales profitability (for D2C brands) or for broader marketing and brand visibility (for large, established brands with strong offline presence). This distinction will guide your investment and performance metrics.
Research and identify an optimal market price range for your product that balances consumer appeal with robust online profitability. Aim for a price point that allows for comfortable coverage of all operational and marketing expenses, ideally around the ₹1500 mark for risk mitigation.
Focus on identifying products or services for online channels that naturally align with low logistics costs and high-profit margins. When engaging potential partners or clients, emphasize how their offerings fit into a sustainable e-commerce model, rather than just market demand.
From conception, prioritize product characteristics that support strong online margins. This includes thoughtful consideration of pricing, weight, and volume. Avoid the trap of passion projects that are inherently unprofitable in an e-commerce context, focusing instead on viable categories.
Understand if your online marketing is driving direct, profitable sales or serving as a brand visibility tool for an offline-first business. Allocate budgets and measure success metrics accordingly, avoiding strategies that generate traffic but not sustainable online revenue for D2C brands.
Gain a foundational understanding of the unique cost structures of e-commerce, especially concerning logistics and margins. This knowledge is crucial for evaluating business ideas, identifying viable career paths in D2C, and making informed decisions in a rapidly evolving digital marketplace.
The product category and the product has to be chosen keeping in mind that online sales margins should be supportive of the margin the product is getting and the price it is getting.
Join thousands of Indian professionals learning from industry experts.
Explore All Courses →